Two recent announcements from Warner Music Group (WMG) and SonyBMG Music push
the music industry on an irrevocable path to abandonment of DRM for permanent paid downloads
over the Internet. Just before the New Year, WMG
announced that it will be joining EMI and Universal Music Group (UMG) in
offering unprotected MP3-format tracks on Amazon.com.
SonyBMG followed suit with a
similar announcement today, a week after making a much more limited
announcement about a few dozen albums it will distribute as physical cards in retail stores that contain codes for downloading
MP3s from a special website. Amazon will offer SonyBMG MP3s starting later
this month.
The primary impetus for this move is a strategic
attempt to destabilize Apple's dominant market position in the industry.
Neither WMG or SonyBMG are (to our knowledge) giving up DRM on iTunes, as only EMI (among the
majors) has to date. All four majors -- plus thousands of indie
labels -- are putting wood behind the Amazon arrowhead against Apple. This is clearly
the music industry's best hope at creating real competition in the online music
retail market, and early indications are that Amazon's MP3 sales are doing quite
well.
Meanwhile, Napster announced last week that it will be moving to MP3s only for its
download sales sometime in the second quarter of 2008. Last Friday's
announcement gave no indication of which labels will support this move, but
the announcement did suggest that Napster will not sell encrypted files anymore.
It will still use DRM (Windows Media DRM) for its core subscription service.
Napster's primary competitor, RealNetworks' Rhapsody, has been offering MP3s
for sale for the past several months, but alongside DRM-protected tracks.
Napster was clearly betting that all four majors will make their entire catalogs
available without DRM -- at least to Napster -- by mid-year. That now
appears highly likely and may even happen sooner. When it does, then the market will have settled on a combination of monthly on-demand
subscriptions with DRM and DRM-free permanent paid downloads in MP3.
Apple will soon have to decide whether to keep iTunes as it is and continue
to rely on the popularity of iPods, or to join in the subscription market.
Subscription services like Rhapsody and Napster currently suffer from a
combination of lack of iPod interoperability and glitches in compatibility with
Windows Media-based portable players. Apple may have an opportunity to
leap to the top of this market by offering a seamless combination of
subscription and portable device transfer. Starting next week, when Apple
is expected to launch an online movie rental service, we should be able to get
insight into whether or how it can upgrade its FairPlay DRM to handle time-based
content rights management.