RealNetworks
launched a major upgrade to its Rhapsody online music service on Tuesday.
Buried somewhat beneath the bevy of enhancements for end-users is an increasing
dependency on Microsoft Windows Media DRM rather than RealNetworks's own
HelixDRM. RealNetworks is using the Windows Media DRM for Portable Devices
technology to offer music portability in the same manner as Napster, which it
now sees as its principal competitor in the online music market.
At a macro level, RealNetworks has essentially bundled RealPlayer Music
Store, its paid-download service, and parts of RealJukebox, its personal music
organization application, in with Rhapsody. Whereas Rhapsody has been an on-demand
streaming service that allows CD burns for some music tracks, it's now a
download service as well. Downloads expire when a user's subscription
lapses, but they are accessible when the user is offline. The service also
offers permanent downloads for sale, with paid subscribers getting a discount.
As with the standalone version of RealPlayer Music Store that
launched last
summer, users can download files in their choice of RealAudio, Windows Media
Audio, and Apple iTunes formats (and RealNetworks claims that it has fixed
compatibility
problems with some recent iPods).
RealNetworks had little choice in its move to embrace Windows Media DRM for
its Rhapsody To Go service. It has to compete with Napster on portable
device support, and HelixDRM does not support anywhere near the number of
different portable music players that Microsoft's DRM does. There is also
evidence to suggest -- though RealNetworks has been quiet about it -- that
Rhapsody was originally based on Microsoft Windows Media technology and was
never changed after RealNetworks acquired the service from Listen.com in 2003.
Yet all this is part of RealNetworks's strategy to recast itself as a content
service provider rather than as a platform company. Just as its longtime
ally Sun Microsystems eventually capitulated and started offering computers that
can run Windows in addition to its own Solaris operating system, RealNetworks is
now sleeping with the enemy even as it carves out a differentiating strategy.
And in terms of the company's success as a music service provider, the
strategy is working. The new Rhapsody is loaded with attractive new
features for users. The upgrade leapfrogs both Napster and MusicMatch in overall
functionality and design, and cements our view of it as the best online music
service, particularly for adventurous music fans. Besides the "To Go"
moniker for its portable-device transfer feature, playlist sharing is another
feature that Rhapsody appropriates from Napster. RealNetworks has upped
the music sampling rate to a maximum of 192kbps, which approaches true CD
quality, for broadband subscribers. Graphics and user interface are
also improved.
And best of all, RealNetworks is offering streams of up to 25 songs per month
for free, just for registering. This aggressive attempt to capture market
share is similar to the one that RealNetworks offered when it launched
RealPlayer Music Store late last year: 49-cent downloads. RealNetworks is paying
royalties on those "free" tracks and making it up through various promotional
deals (including, we imagine, sharing registrants' email addresses with marketing partners).
The battle over online music services is becoming fiercer and fiercer, as DRM
for online music effectively becomes a three-way market (Apple, Microsoft, and
the rising OMA DRM standard in Europe). Service providers are battling it out
over features and price, and the music industry is cooperating with appropriate
licensing deals in its attempt to
launch viable paid alternatives to file-sharing services. Our
view has
been that market forces will trump all -- even whatever decision comes out of
the Grokster case before the Supreme Court -- in determining the eventual
winners.